Customer Satisfaction—the Ultimate Vanity Metric?

Almost every company measures Customer Satisfaction or its variations at considerable expense and effort.

Some companies attempt to use the metric for advertising. The metric is supposed to convince a shopper to join the ranks of the company’s customers because they are supposedly 97% satisfied. These numbers are impossible for a consumer to validate, methodologically or anecdotally. Besides, there may be information floating in Social Media that disputes the company’ customer satisfaction claims, however unfairly. In my opinion, brandishing the customer satisfaction scores, without complete transparency, will more likely lead to erosion of trust than to increase in sales. Social Customers trust each other’s experiences more than they do brand claims.

csat bullshitMany companies use the customer satisfaction metric to judge departmental performance while their customers keep churning, for reasons the measured business unit may have no control over whatsoever. They do well if the last calendar period metric is scored higher than the previous one. If the last score is lower, bonuses are not paid and changes to a status quo are demanded. Sometimes the change is a switch to different methodology of measuring customer satisfaction.

Disconnect from the Customer Satisfaction Score, regardless of methodology, and from specific and systematic action that targets improvement of customer experience, makes the score an ultimate vanity metric.

Richard H. Levey wrote thatbullshit survey

“True customer insight requires first knowing (discovering) which attributes matter to the customer and then determining how the firm is performing on those attributes. If a customer’s experience occurs over multiple interactions and various media, then each needs to be measured to drive insight precision. ”   Stop Measuring Customer Satisfaction and Start Understanding It. (emphasis mine).

I would add-stop counting the clicks, “likes” and re-tweets, and start understanding WHY customers do what they do. Stop tabulating survey scores and start reading the comments—you may learn something that would help promote an action of positive change.

This entry was posted in Customer Experience CX and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Customer Satisfaction—the Ultimate Vanity Metric?

  1. Pingback: Customer Satisfaction — the Ultimate Vanity Metric?

  2. Pingback: Three Ways You Haven't Tried for Improving Customer Satisfaction - Rabid Office Monkey for Business

  3. Pingback: Vanity Metrics – How Is This Still A Thing? | Customer Experience IQ Blog

  4. Pingback: Vanity Metrics: How Is This Still A Thing?

  5. Pingback: Is it Wise to Ignore Correlations Between Customer Experience and Creation of Wealth? | Customer Experience IQ Blog

  6. Pingback: Is it Wise to Ignore Correlations Between Customer Experience and Creation of Wealth? | Internet Marketing

  7. Pingback: Four predictions prescriptions for CEM clarity in 2015 | Digital Clarity Group | Consultancy, Research, Events, Technology and Agency Selections, CEM, WCM, CMS, DAM, CRM, E-Commerce, Social Media, Marketing Automation, Governance, Customer Experience

  8. Pingback: Wise To Ignore Correlations Between Experience And Wealth?

  9. Pingback: Customer Satisfaction Is Not Enough to Forge Loyalty | Customer Experience IQ Blog

  10. Pingback: Customer Satisfaction Is Not Enough to Forge Loyalty | Yahoo Small Business Advisor

  11. It is true that qualitative analysis can and should have a more important part in measuring customer satisfaction.

  12. Rachel says:

    Thanks for this post, I am a big big fan of this internet site would like to go along updated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *